There are of course many e collar/remote trainer brands and models on the market, and we’re not going to say that one specific remote trainer/e collar is good for every dog and every scenario.
However, when looking for the best e collar or remote trainer for a German Shepherd, there are couple of very popular models from SportDOG and Dogtra that perform extremely well as all around trainers
These models are the SportDOG Field Trainer 425 and 425s (for the regular trainer/owner), and the Dogtra 1900s (for the slightly more advanced trainer/owner).
Let’s check them both out!
(NOTE: this is a general information guide only, and is not professional advice, or a substitute for professional advice. A qualified vet or animal expert is the only person qualified to give you expert advice in regards to your pet/s)
Best E Collar, Shock Collar & Remote Trainer For A German Shepherd
Our top picks for the best e colllar for a German Shepherd are:
SportDOG FieldTrainer 425 (on Amazon) – Best Standard/Basic E Collar For German Shepherd, Neck Sizes 5-22 Inches
SportDOG FieldTrainer 425s (on Amazon) – Best Standard/Basic E Collar For More Stubborn German Shepherds, Neck Sizes 5-22 Inches
Dogtra 1900S (on Amazon) – Best Advanced E Collar For German Shepherds 35lbs and Over
Best E Collar & Remote Trainer For German Shepherd: Review
SportDOG Field Trainer 425
- This is a dog training collar/e collar receiver, that comes with a handheld remote transmitter with controls for functions
- Overall, it’s one of the best of it’s kind on the market
- It allows you to work with static stimulation, vibration and tone
- The transmitter has a 500 yard range to the receiver/collar
- The transmitter’s dial allows you to select one of the 7 levels of static stimulation in low or medium ranges
- The transmitter’s buttons allow you to deliver your choice of momentary (nick) or continuous stimulation
- You also have the option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep)
- Both the Remote Transmitter and Collar Receiver feature DryTek technology making them waterproof and submersible to 25 feet
- The devices have rechargeable lithium-ion batteries that charge in 2 hours and last 50-70 hours per charge
- Both the Transmitter and Collar feature a low battery indicator and can be charged at the same time using the included split-end charger
- The Transmitter button functions can be customized
- You can train up to 3 dogs with the same Remote Transmitter with purchase of additional Add-A-Dog Collars (SDR-AF) – SDR-AF Collar Receiver (on Amazon).
- The Collar Receiver fits dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5″ – 22″
- With the transmitter and collar kit, you get a detailed operating guide, training DVD, and a Customer Care Center, available 6 days a week, provide support when you need it
- Comes in both black and camo colors
- Overall, the SportDOG products are designed with the heat, cold, rain, snow, dust, mud, and wind in mind
- SportDOG provide some of the best customer support we’ve seen compared to other companies
- Works better in wider open areas than areas of lots of obstacles and obstructions
- The charger connectors don’t stay super secure while charging. You’ll have to make sure you have them securely jacked in before you leave the transmitter and collar to charge
- No LCD display. If there isn’t much light out or you don’t have a light source, it can be hard to see the dial setting
- The layout and default functions of the buttons and dial are pretty good, but could use some more improvement
- Overall, despite the drawbacks, this is one of the better e collars on the market, despite it’s price. It’s definitely worth the money
SportDOG Field Trainer 425s
The SD-425S is essentially the same e collar and transmitter as the 425, except it has a higher range of stimulation than the SD-425.
It is designed specifically for larger, harder to train, or more stubborn dogs that don’t or won’t respond to lower level stimulus.
So, if you know you have a stubborn dog, or you’ve tried lower level static stimulus training collars that your dog won’t respond to, this one could be better for you.
As the two products are essentially the same, you can read our review of the SportDOG 425 here.
You’ll be able to see all the features and drawbacks of the 425s in that review.
- Designed for the most demanding conditions, and for serious amateurs and professional trainers in pet obedience, hunting, competition trials, and K-9.
- Overall, it is high quality, and when assessing it for the features it does have, it is one of the best dog training collar systems on the market
- Has 3/4-mile range
- Is fully waterproof (waterproof certified to IPX9K)
- Has 127 different levels of static stimulation/shock for the most sensitive through to the most stubborn dogs
- Control the static stimulation level through an easy to twist dial
- Has both nick (temporary) and continuous static stimulation/shock options
- Comes with a vibration option
- Has an LCD display on the handheld remote which has an illuminated blue background – good for darker conditions
- For dogs 35 lbs and over
- Comes with a belt clip for the handheld remote
- Batteries charge in 2 hours
- Comes with short contact points only
- Collar fits most medium to extra large and Giant dogs
- Dogtra does a Black Edition with increased range and LED lighting – check out the Dogtra 1900S Black Edition here.
- Dogtra does a Wetlands edition of the 1900S for wetland hunters – check out the Dogtra 1900S Wetlands Edition here.
- Not for dogs smaller than 35lbs
- Doesn’t have a tone/sound training mode (only static and vibration)
- Comes with short contact points only – you’ll have to buy long contact points separately for longer hair breeds
- Designed for controlling only one dog at a time. You can’t control or train multiple dogs from the one handheld remote like you can with the SportDOG or Garmin models
- Despite these drawbacks, overall, this is a very very high quality dog training collar system.
Best E Collar & Remote Trainer For German Shepherd: Buyer’s Guide
What Is An E Collar or Shock Collar or Remote Trainer
E collars and shock collars or remote trainers can best be described as training devices to encourage or discourage certain behaviours in a dog at a distance
They consist of a controller, and a receiver (the collar & receiver unit) which interact with each other.
So, the owner or trainer controls the collar from a distance/range instantaneously
A GOOD e collar or shock collar does not cause pain to the dog.
Rather, it allows the owner to send a range of stimulus to the dog – the main three being a tone/sound, a vibration or low wave painless electric stimulation (more an alert that goes to the neck muscles).
E Collars and Remote Trainers should be distinguished from bark collars which come without a handheld device to control the collar. Bark Collars automatically function on their own, whilst remote trainers function manually.
E Collar vs Shock Collar vs Remote Training Collar – Difference, & Similarity
Shock collar is probably an old term used to describe these devices.
Shock collars in years gone by have traditionally only been designed to send an ‘electric shock’ to the dog when they carry out a behaviour their owner is trying to discourage.
Even the cheaper shock collars these days might still do this (which is why it’s wise not to go cheap with a training collar – the more expensive collars come from more established companies with more knowledge).
Nowadays, the reputable companies are making ‘E Collars’ & ‘Training Collars’ which are part of a remote handheld system that controls the collar.
Their collars have arguably better features like the ability to send sounds, vibrations or stimulations as cues to the dog, to make it less about shocking the dog, and more about alerting them when they feel or hear the stimulus they are trained to react to.
The good e collars and training collars have a wide range of stimulation frequencies (shock frequencies) so you can find the lowest possible stimulation level your dog will respond to (providing an undesirable sensation, but not pain).
Types Of E Collars & Shock Collars
E Collars and remote trainers could be categorised by type based on some of the following features they may or may not have:
- The distance they allow the owner to be from the dog
- Whether it’s a 1 dog, or multiple dog training system
- What options the collar has for sending a cue to your dog – 3 main ones are sound, vibrate or static stimulation (very low frequency shock)
When You Might Use An E Collar Or Shock Collar For Your German Shepherd
You might look at using an e collar AFTER you’ve done or looked at the following:
- Once you’ve worked on building a strong bond with your dog & you have their trust
- Once you’ve undertaken basic obedience with your dog, or advanced training courses
- Once positive reinforcement training has failed to work
- Once you’ve consulted the advice of a professional dog trainer, and your vet (it’s usually safer to use the shock collar in the presence of a professional trainer who has deep knowledge of animal behavior & the use of shock/vibration collars)
- Once you’ve consulted the laws in your area as to the use of e collars & shock collars
- Once you’ve done your own research on the case studies of use of shock collars and e collars
For example, some people find that e collars & shock collars work well for off the leash re-call when positive training in particular doesn’t suffice.
Another example might be in teaching their dog the acceptable boundaries to explore on their property (and not go wandering or running away).
Put it this way – if you are facing a situation where you have the choice of using an e collar, or perhaps your dog’s behavior might mean they might be re-homed or worse, put down, if you don’t find a solution quickly, an e collar might be the best and logical choice – at least in the short term.
It’s worth noting that many owners might simply use the e collar to teach their dog a certain behavior, and are then able to store away the e collar once the behavior is learned.
They don’t have to be a permanent thing.
Remote training collars can also be used for professional dog training, K-9 training, and hunting for example
What Size E Collar Or Shock Collar To Get For A German Shepherd?
Measure your dog’s neck size (circumference), and weight them.
Then check what weight of dog, and the neck size that the e collar is designed for e.g. an e collar might be designed for dogs 8lbs and over, with a neck size between 5-22 inches for example.
A German Shepherd is generally a large breed dog with on average a neck size somewhere between 20-25 inches, and weighs 75-95 lbs.
What E Collar or Shock Collar To Get For A German Shepherd Puppy?
Consult your dog’s vet about when you can start using an e collar on your dog.
For puppies, some of the reputable brands might say to start using the collar after 6 months old or when the dog is 8lbs or larger. But, read the product description and owner’s manual for the e collar you are looking at purchasing.
Are E Collars & Shock Collars Safe?
Good e and shock collars are designed to deliver simply a low ‘warning’ type of stimulation/electric charge to your dog.
They should deliver a pulsing, tingling or tickling sensation on the surface of the skin.
They are not intended to cause pain, but rather just an undesirable feeling to your dog to signal to them that a particular behavior is undesirable.
As mentioned above, you can even set some collar to vibrate or sound based warnings which are completely painless.
Always read the product manufacturer usage instructions carefully.
Your dog’s vet is the only one qualified to give your professional advice on the use of e collar for your dog – especially if your dog has existing health conditions, or is at risk of developing them.
More Information On The Use Of E Collars & Shock Collars
- The Evolution of electronic training devices, and facts about the modern e collars (great downloadble report inside with heaps of referenced info)
- E Collar Training Information
- Dogtra Training Tips
- Shock collars illegal and restricted in some parts of Europe
- Shock Collars vs E Collars
- 5 Myths About Shock Collars & E Collars
- One scientific case study on the use shock collars
Friendly Disclaimers 🙂
thedailyshep.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of Amazon.com Inc., or its affiliates
TheDailyShep.com are not veterinarians, or animal professionals/experts. Information provided is for informational purposes only – it is not a substitute for professional or qualified advice.
The information is based on either our own thorough research, and/or own experiences, as a means of free speech.
By consuming this information, you accept that TheDailyShep.com do not have client or patient relationship with you, and TheDailyShep.com are not advising you to act on anything you read.
You should always consult your own veterinarian, animal expert, or health care professional and follow their advice before making decisions on all matters.
You can find our full set of disclaimers and T & C’s in the footer of this site.
Enjoy your reading, and thank you for being here 🙂