We’ve chosen to do a SportDOG vs PetSafe vs Dogtra vs Garmin Bark Collar Comparison and Reviews guide because these are some of the most reputable brands on the market and in the pet industry.
No bark control collar is perfect, but the collars from these companies along with their customer service and commitment to quality of their products is as good as you’ll get from anyone.
We’ve outlined some of the most popular bark collars and models from each brand, and also linked you to individual reviews for each collar.
You should be able to quickly and clearly see which brand and collar model might suit your dog/s and your preferences.
Let’s check them out!
(NOTE: this is a general information guide only, and is not professional advice, or a substitute for professional advice. A qualified vet or animal expert is the only person qualified to give you expert advice in regards to your pet/s)
(*Friendly Disclosure – links to retailers or brands on this page may include affiliate links, and we may receive a commission when you purchase through these links)
SportDOG vs PetSafe vs Dogtra vs Garmin Bark Collars: Comparison
If you prefer, you can go straight to viewing one of the popular SportDOG collars here:
- SportDOG NoBark SBC-R Rechargeable Bark Control Dog Collar (on Chewy)
- SportDOG SBC-R No Bark Collar (on Amazon)
Additionally, you can view some of the best dog bark collars on the market at the moment in this guide.
Onto the comparisons …
SportDOG Bark Control Collars
SportDOG has static stimulation bark collars.
Their latest bark collar, the SBC-R, is one of the most advanced and reliable on the market with a rechargeable lithium ion battery, different static stimulation modes to choose from, and intuitive bark sensor technology.
You can see a SportDOG bark collar comparison guide here.
Some other SportDOG reviews can be found below.
SportDOG SBC-R Bark Control Collar
For dogs 8 lbs or larger with neck sizes 5-22 inches.
Uses static stimulation and has 10 levels of static stimulation to choose from.
3 training modes to choose from – Temperament Learning, Progressive Correction, or User-Selected.
Has Silent Partner™ technology that is supposed to identify your dog’s own unique bark, an OLED display screen, and a rechargeable lithium ion battery.
The latest of SportDOG’s bark collars.
SportDOG SBC-R Bark Control Collar Review
SportDOG SBC-10R Bark Control Collar
For dogs 8 lbs or larger with neck sizes 5-22 inches.
Uses static stimulation and has 10 levels of static stimulation to choose from.
3 training modes to choose from – Temperament Learning, Progressive Correction, or User-Selected.
SportDOG SBC-10R Bark Control Collar Review
SportDOG SBC-18 Bark Control Collar
For dogs with neck sizes 5-22 inches.
Has 6 levels of static stimulation with low/medium/high stimulation ranges – you select the stimulation range and the collar does the rest
With the levels and ranges, you really get 18 different levels available (6 in each range).
SportDOG SBC-18 Bark Control Collar Review
SportDOG SBC-6 Bark Control Collar
For dogs with neck sizes 5-22 inches.
It includes 6 levels of static stimulation, with no programming required – the collar adjusts the static level automatically as your dog continues to bark.
SportDOG SBC-6 Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Bark Control Collars
PetSafe has the widest range of anti-bark collars available.
Their range covers everything from static, to vibration, to sound to spray bark collars.
Two of the most popular collars are the Basic Bark Collar and the Deluxe Bark Collar, which are static stimulation correction collars.
Some of PetSafe’s most popular anti-bark collars are:
PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar
A very popular collar that is also affordable.
It has progressive correction which means the static levels automatically adjust without you having to set or modify settings
There’s 6 different levels of static stimulation.
PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Deluxe Bark Control Collar
Another popular and affordable collar.
It has progressive correction with 6 different levels of static stimulation as well.
However, you can choose between low, medium and high power output ranges for the static stimulation – for softer through to harder to train dogs.
This gives the Deluxe 18 different levels of static overall.
PetSafe Deluxe Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Elite Little Dog Bark Control Collar
For dogs 8 to 55 lb. with neck sizes up to 22″ – so mainly smaller dogs.
There is a static stimulation training option with 10 levels of static stimulation – the collar automatically adjusts and increases in static levels as your dog continues to bark.
PetSafe Elite Little Dog Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Elite Big Dog Bark Collar
For dogs 40lbs + with neck sizes up to 28″ – so mainly medium to large dogs.
Also has the static stimulation training option with 10 levels of static stimulation – the collar automatically adjusts and increases in static levels as your dog continues to bark.
PetSafe Elite Big Dog Bark Collar Review
PetSafe Rechargeable Bark Control Collar
For dogs 8lbs and up, and for owners who want a lithium ion rechargeable battery.
It has a static correction training mode which adjusts the static level according to how often the dog barks with Temperament learning.
There’s 15 adjustable levels of static correction overall.
PetSafe Rechargeable Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Big Dog Rechargeable Bark Control Collar
For dogs 40lbs and up, and for owners who want a rechargeable battery.
It has 10 adjustable levels of static correction, and has 3 modes of correction to choose from: temperament learning, progressive correction, and manual/user-selected mode.
PetSafe Big Dog Rechargeable Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe Vibration Bark Control Collar
A vibration only bark control collar that.
There’s 10 combinations of vibration correction from less intense to more intense vibrations.
PetSafe Vibration Bark Control Collar Review
PetSafe GentleSpray Anti-Bark Control Collar
A bark control collar that works with citronella spray.
You fill the collar device up with citronella liquid, and the collar delivers a soft spray when your dog barks.
Very popular, but perhaps not the most effective bark collar as it is sensitive, can leak and not all dogs are deterred by citronella spray.
PetSafe Gentle Spray Anti-Bark Control Review
PetSafe Ultrasonic Bark Control Collar
Recommended for single dog households only.
This collar emits a high pitched ultrasonic tone to train a dog to minimise their barking. The tone is inaudible to most humans
There’s a sound sensor microphone that detects sound in your dog’s bark to trigger the ultrasonic tone.
Overall, the technology on this collar doesn’t seem to be super effective.
PetSafe Ultrasonic Bark Control Collar Review
Dogtra Bark Control Collars
Dogtra has a bark collar for smaller dogs in the YS300, and one for bigger dogs in the YS600.
Both feature vibration stimulation as part of the collar functioning.
The more popular anti-bark collars from Dogtra are:
Dogtra YS300 Bark Control Collar
Smallest and most compact no bark collar in the Dogtra range.
Has a static training mode with Low-Mid stimulation power output in 1-6 levels.
There’s a non-stimulating Pager Vibration warning before static stimulation is delivered.
For dogs 10lbs and over, and with 9 to 20 inch necks.
Dogtra YS300 Bark Control Collar Review
Dogtra YS600 Bark Control Collar
No bark collar for bigger or more stubborn dogs of 35 lbs and up.
Has both static stimulation, and vibration only training options.
The static stimulation has 10 different levels of varying intensity static.
The static power output is low to high, so can be used for soft up to harder temperament or more stubborn dogs.
The vibration is the High Performance Pager (HPP) vibration training option.
Dogtra YS600 Bark Control Collar Review
Dogtra YS300 vs YS600 Comparison
You can some of the best dog bark collars on the market at the moment in this guide.
Dogtra iQ No Bark Collar
Comes in a range of colors, and is for dogs 10lbs and up – more of a collar for small dogs.
For dogs with a neck size of 8” to 18”.
Has a static stimulation mode with 10 different levels of static stimulation adjustable on the collar.
Static stimulation power output is low to medium for soft to more mild temperament and easier to train dogs
Has Learning Vibration feature that gives a warning vibration prior to correction.
Dogtra iQ No Bark Collar Review
Garmin Bark Control Collars
Garmin has the BarkLimiter range of Bark collars with the BarkLimiter 2 being the latest:
Garmin BarkLimiter 2 Bark Collar
The newest BarkLimiter collar – the model 2 version.
Works on rechargeable lithium ion batteries with up to 30 days battery life on a charge
There’s a static stimulation only mode – with 10 levels of static to choose from.
Static can be manual where you choose a level, or you can use the automatic progression mode where the static level increases as your dog continues to bark
There’s also a tone and vibration mode – where the collar beeps before vibrating when your dog barks
This collar works with the Garmin Canine™ app on your smartphone to let you adjust settings and review bark correction data
LED light on the device indicates battery life, bark detection and correction.
Garmin BarkLimiter 2 Bark Collar Review
Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Bark Collar
The major difference between the Deluxe and the standard BarkLimiter is that the Deluxe has rechargeable Li-ion batteries that last about 3 months per charge.
Has a static stimulation training mode with 7 different levels of static.
Has autorise correction technology that automatically adjusts the level of the static according to your dog’s barking consistency.
Also has a fixed correction mode in case you want to use one static level only.
Has a vibration only training mode as well.
Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Bark Collar Review
Garmin BarkLimiter Bark Collar
Has replaceable batteries are CR2 batteries and last about 10 months.
Has a static stimulation training mode with 7 different levels of static.
Has autorise correction technology that automatically adjusts the level of the static according to your dog’s barking consistency.
Also has a fixed correction mode in case you want to use one static level only.
Has a vibration only training mode as well.
Garmin BarkLimiter Bark Collar Review
Friendly Disclaimers
TheDailyShep.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates.
Additionally, TheDailyShep.com participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links.
TheDailyShep.com are not veterinarians, or animal professionals/experts. Information provided is for informational purposes only – it is not a substitute for professional or qualified advice.
The information is based on either our own thorough research, and/or own experiences, as a means of free speech.
By consuming this information, you accept that TheDailyShep.com do not have client or patient relationship with you, and TheDailyShep.com are not advising you to act on anything you read.
You should always consult your own veterinarian, animal expert, or health care professional and follow their advice before making decisions on all matters.
You can find our full set of disclaimers and T & C’s in the footer of this site.
Enjoy your reading, and thank you for being here
','' ); } ?>