Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Comparison, & Which Is Better?


You might be looking at the differences in Dogtra’s remote dog collar training systems.

In this case, you’ll want to have a look over this Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP comparison guide where we clearly outline the differences and similarities between the two e collar models.

We also consider which might be better for different types of owners and trainers, and consider what they are each designed for.

Let’s check them out in closer detail.


(NOTE: this is a general information guide only, and is not professional advice, or a substitute for professional advice. A qualified vet or animal expert is the only person qualified to give you expert advice in regards to your pet/s)

(*Friendly Disclosure – links to retailers or brands on this page may include affiliate links, and we may receive a commission when you purchase through these links)


Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Comparison, & Which Is Better?

You can go straight to viewing the Dogtra 1900S or 2300NCP here:

**You can purchase long contact points for the collar separately (only short contact points come with the system) – Dogtra Stainless Steel Contact Points (on Amazon) 


  • Dogtra 2300NCP E Collar (on Amazon) (this product description says 1 dog system, but it should be updated to the expandable 2 dog system – confirm with the seller before ordering just to be sure)

**You can purchase long contact points for the collar separately (only short contact points come with the system) – Dogtra Stainless Steel Contact Points (on Amazon) 


If you want to look at some of Dogtra’s other remote training collars, you can read this guide.


Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Which Might Be Better For You?

To be completely honest, these two e collars are almost exactly the same in what they offer from a features perspective.

It really comes down to…

– You’d get the 1900S if you want a 1 dog system

– You’d get the 2300NCP if you want an e collar system that can expand to take 2 dogs in total controllable from the handheld remote (if you purchase an additional Dogtra 2300NCP collar receiver device)


Having said that, the 1900S has the 1902S which is the 2 dog system of the 1900S model anyway, which makes the 2300NCP a little bit redundant.

The 1900S overall in our opinion is probably a better option because it has more alternative models available, and is more popular.

Both are designed for similar types of activities.

The 1900S is designed for the most demanding conditions, and for serious amateurs and professional trainers in pet obedience, hunting, competition trials, and K-9. 

The 2300NCP for is designed for all types of dog training, and especially for advanced level pet training, competition training, Police K-9 work, or any types of hunting


Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Differences

The major difference is that the 1900S is a 1 dog system, whilst the 2300 is a 1 dog system that is expandable up to 2 dogs.

The 2300NCP is expandable to 2 dogs being controlled on the same remote, if you purchase an extra collar receiver (the 2300NCP model collar receiver). The 2300NCP remote also looks slightly different with color coded buttons for the second dog.

Dogtra does a 2 dog system of the 1900S – check out the Dogtra 1902 2 Dog System here.

Dogtra does a Black Edition of the 1900S with increased range and LED lighting – check out the Dogtra 1900S Black Edition here.

Dogtra does a Wetlands edition of the 1900S for wetland hunters – check out the Dogtra 1900S Wetlands Edition here.


Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Similarities

Both can be used on most dogs from softer to harder temperaments

Both have Has a 3/4 mile from the handhled remote to the collar receiver device

Both have 127 different levels of low to high static stimulation controllable from a dial on top of the remote

Both have both continuous and momentary static stimulation options

Both have a vibration training option

Both have 2 hour quick charge batteries

Both are fully waterproof

Both have an LCD on the front of the remote that allows you to see battery level and the static stimulation level

Both are for dogs as small as 35lbs


Dogtra 1900S vs 2300NCP: Reviews

Dogtra 1900 Review

Dogtra 1900 Black Edition Review

Dogtra 1900 Wetlands Edition Review

Dogtra 1902 2 Dog System Review

Dogtra 2300NCP Review


Other E Collars & Remote Dog Training Dog Collars

You can read about some of the best overall e collars and remote dog training collars from different brands in this guide.


E Collar & Remote Dog Training Collar Buyers & FAQ Guide

You can read this guide which is an e collar and remote dog training collar buyers guide and FAQ guide.

In it, information is provided on the following:

What some of the best e collars might be

Factors to consider in deciding which e collar to buy

What the cost of an e collar is 

What size e collar to get

What is an e collar

Types of e collars

What is an e collar used for, and why use one

How to use an e collar

How to put an e collar on your dog

How to train a dog with an e collar

At what age to start using an e collar, and how long training takes

When you might consider using an e collar

Safety considerations for using an e collar

E collars vs bark collars


What Size E Collar/Remote Dog Training Collar Do I Get?

In terms of size of the e collar, you might look for two main things:

– The weight range of the collar i.e. it might say ‘for dogs 8lbs and over’

– The neck size that the collar fits i.e. it might say for dogs with neck sizes 6 to 28 inches



– Find out the weight of your dog

– Measure their neck size and compare it to the collar strap length that the collar comes with

– And, make sure you follow the manufacturer’s sizing specifications for the e collar you want


Safety Considerations With A Remote Dog Training Collar

Safety is extremely important with a remote dog training collar.

Always always get your vet’s advice or the advice of an animal health and/or training expert – nothing is a substitute for professional advice.

Some general safety guidelines for using an e collar humanely might be:

Buy from a reputable company who put proper use of the e collar and the safety of the dog as a priority 

Read and follow the operating guide, instruction/safety manual and training guide that comes with the e collar system from the manufacturer for operation and safety instructions and guidelines

Pay attention to any warnings issued by the manufacturer

Monitor your dog’s response both mentally and physically to using an e collar. Take the collar off immediately and discontinue use of the system if you notice any negative implications or reactions


A good remote dog training collar that uses static stimulation should simply stimulate the muscle (to the point of reflex) to get the dog’s attention, but should not cause pain (it might be slightly annoying for the dog to act as a small deterrent – but shouldn’t cause pain or harm). It certainly shouldn’t cause a ‘sharp pain’ to the muscle or body. 

To get a safe stimulation level – you can always start from the lowest stimulation level, and work your way up to a level that gets the dog’s attention (such as changing body language when a stimulation, vibration or tone is administered) without any visible sign of pain or harm (such as yelping, or showing signs of stress).

A good e collar company should give you all the necessary safety, use and training instructions, and should have a dedicated customer service line to help when you being using the collar system.

The static stimulation function does not need to be used either – tone and vibrate training modes can be used instead.

Some owners like to even use their e collar as a temporary training tool, and may go back to using body or verbal commands once behaviors are reinforced (if suitable).



Friendly Disclaimers is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of, Inc., or its affiliates.

Additionally, participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. are not veterinarians, or animal professionals/experts. Information provided is for informational purposes only – it is not a substitute for professional or qualified advice.

The information is based on either our own thorough research, and/or own experiences, as a means of free speech.

By consuming this information, you accept that do not have client or patient relationship with you, and are not advising you to act on anything you read.

You should always consult your own veterinarian, animal expert, or health care professional and follow their advice before making decisions on all matters.


You can find our full set of disclaimers and T & C’s in the footer of this site.


Enjoy your reading, and thank you for being here 

Leave a Comment