Best Anti Bark Collar For German Shepherd

0

 

When it comes to the use of anti bark collars on your German Shepherd, we have similar things to say about them that we did remote controlled shock collars and e collars.

We do not definitively say they are right or wrong for each owner and dog’s situation.

It depends on a range of factors (which we list in the buyer’s guide below), and ultimately comes down to your final decision (in conjunction with advice from a professional trainer/behaviouralist and/or vet).

A bark correction device might be worth a look where you you’ve either tried everything else, or you have limited time to find a solution to your dog’s barking problem.

Some owners have had great success with them in these instances.

In this guide, we discuss anti bark collars, & identify when you might look at getting one. We also identify what the best bark collar for German Shepherd dogs might be.

Let’s go into more detail…

 

Best Anti Bark Collar For German Shepherd

In case you don’t have time to read the reviews, and buyer’s guide, these are our top four anti bark collar choices:

SportDOG Rechargeable Bark Control Collar (on Amazon)  – Best Value Anti Bark Collar

Other Popular & High Quality Anti Bark Collar Options

Dogtra YS-600 No Bark Collar (on Amazon) 

Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Dog Training Device (on Amazon) 

Garmin PT10 Dog Device Red Collar (on Amazon) 

*NOTE: Garmin was formerly Tri Tronics

 

Best Anti Bark Collar For German Shepherd: Reviews

Dogtra YS-600 No Bark Collar

View On Amazon

What’s Good About It?

  • Accelerometer bark sensor for more accurate barking sensing
  • Persistent Bark indicator alerts dog owners of excessive barking each time the unit is turned off
  • Smaller and lighter than previous Dogtra high powered no bark collars
  • Outputs Low-High stimulation from 1-10 intensity levels > finds the right stimulation for all breeds and temperaments
  • Has a non-stimulating High Performance Pager (HPP) vibration that has a more vibrant sensation than a traditional pager
  • Is fully waterproof and equipped with plastic shielded 5/8″ Enhanced Contact Points
  • 2-Hour Rapid Charge Batteries – these are re-chargeable
  • Can fit to dogs as small as 35 lbs

What Could Be Improved?

  • Barking sensor system isn’t perfect but still works OK. Might sometimes stimulate/shock your dog while they are doing something other than barking – if this is the case, you may need to try a handheld operated e collar
  • Some people don’t like the YS-600 as much as previous versions – but that is subjective

What Else Might You Get With It?

  • This collar is ready out of the box

Where To Check It Out?

Dogtra YS-600 No Bark Collar (on Amazon) 

 

SportDOG Rechargeable Bark Control Collar

View On Amazon

What’s Good About It?

  • Has 3 modes of operation – temperament learning, progressive stimulation and user selected stimulation
  • Temperament learning starts at the lowest stimulation/shock level, and progresses 1 level higher every time your dog barks until they stop. If barking reduces, the stimulation level reduces.
  • Progressive stimulation increases the level every time your dog barks in a 30 second period. Every time your dog doesn’t bark in a 30 second period, the collar resets to 0.
  • With user selected the collar works at the level you set it at.
  • DryTek™ waterproof and submersible to 25 feet
  • For dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5-22 inches
  • Delivers a static stimulation via the Contact Points only if it detects BOTH vibration from the vocal cords AND the sound of the bark (External noise or another dog’s bark will not trigger a stimulation)
  • Offers 10 levels of static stimulation
  • In built safety feature – if your dog barks 15 times or more within an 80 second period, the NoBark™ SBC-10R will automatically shut off for 3 minutes – safety feature is active in all three modes of operation.
  • Rechargeable NiMH batteries – Charges in 4 hours, lasts 3-6 months per charge

What Could Be Improved?

  • Some owners report red marks being left on the skin if the stimulation intensity level is set too high – follow the instructions of use carefully, monitor use on your dog, and seek qualified advice if you observe markings on your dog

What’s Else Might You Need?

  • Ready out of the box

Where To Check It Out?

SportDOG Rechargeable Bark Control Collar (on Amazon) 

 

 Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Dog Training Device

View On Amazon

What’s Good About It?

  • Has a vibrate option instead of the default stimulation option
  • Fits all dog breeds, all coat thicknesses
  • Includes a user-replaceable CR2 battery (up to 10 months battery life)
  • Has Tri-Tronics® dog training technology
  • Uses accelerometer-based bark identification to distinguish between barking and other sounds. This eliminates the collar triggering on paw scratching or scraping of external surfaces, or other noises like the barks of nearby dogs
  • Has integrated stainless steel contact points
  • Made to work on all dog breeds and coat thicknesses
  • Autorise technology means the collar starts at the lowest correction level and gradually adjusts to a level to stop unwanted barking without rising further.
  • You can also switch from automatic to manual settings. Built-in Bark Odometer™ helps determine the effectiveness of the manual correction level by counting the number of barks while you are away.
  • If you need a replacement collar, BarkLimiter standard collar can be replaced with polyurethane-coated 3/4″ accessory collars, or 3/4″ woven nylon Lupine Collars

What’s Could Be Improved?

  • Sensor system can be unreliable sometimes – can trigger when your dog doesn’t bark, and sometimes doesn’t trigger on every bark

What Else Might You Get With It?

  • Collar is ready to go out of the box.

Where To Check It Out?

Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Dog Training Device (on Amazon) 

 

Garmin PT10 Dog Device Red Collar

Garmin also offers the PT10 Collar which works with the PRO 70 and PRO 550 handhelds.

This is also a high quality bark collar.

Garmin PT10 Dog Device Red Collar (on Amazon) 

 

Best Anti Bark Collar For German Shepherd: Buyer’s Guide

What Are Anti Bark Collars?

Consists of a collar with an anti bark unit attached.

The unit usually has an automatic sensor in it which senses when the dog barks, or it’s vocal cords move, and delivers a vibration or electric stimulation to the dog to discourage the barking.

They differ to shock collars and e collars which are not usually automatic, but remotely controlled by the owner holding control device.

 

Types Of Anti Bark Collars

  • Electric or Vibration Stimulation Bark Collar with automatic sensor
  • Electric or Vibration Stimulation Bark Collar which can be controlled by a handheld device
  • Citronella Bark Collars – usually very unreliable, can leak and be messy and in general work very poorly

 

Do Anti Bark Collars Work?

Yes, there are owners who have used bark collars successfully to decrease or completely stop their dog’s barking.

Sometimes bark collars won’t be as effective as they can be if they have:

  • Poor bark sensing technology (either the collar doesn’t trigger consistenly when your dog barks, or it functions when your dog doesn’t bark)
  • Batteries that run out quickly
  • Contacts (the metal prongs that deliver the stimulation) that aren’t long enough to protrude through your dog’s coat. In this case, you need to buy longer contacts

The cheap anti bark collars are a bit of a waste of time and money.

They usually either aren’t put together very well, are made with poor quality materials, or don’t function properly in terms of when they are suppose to release stimulation.

 

Are Anti Bark Collars Safe?

Good bark collars are designed to deliver simply a low ‘warning’ type of stimulation/electric charge to your dog.

They should deliver a pulsing, tingling or tickling sensation on the surface of the skin.

They are not intended to cause pain, but rather just an undesirable feeling to your dog to signal to them that barking is undesirable.

Always read the product manufacturer usage instructions carefully.

 

When To Use An Anti Bark Collar On Your German Shepherd

Ultimately the decision lies with the owner as to whether they use a bark collar or not.

However, you may use a bark collar:

  • Once you’ve worked on building a strong bond with your dog & you have their trust
  • Once you’ve undertaken basic obedience with your dog, or advanced training courses to minimise or stop the barking
  • Once positive reinforcement training has failed to work
  • Once you’ve consulted the advice of a professional dog trainer, and your vet (it’s usually safer to use the bark collar in the presence of a professional trainer who has deep knowledge of animal behavior & the use of bark collars)
  • Once you’ve consulted the laws in your area as to the use of bark collars
  • Once you’ve done your own research on the case studies of use of bark collars and e collars

There are other special circumstances where a bark collar might be your only option.

For example, in a residential area, if you have a dog that won’t stop barking and it annoys your neighbours to the extent that they make serious complaints to your council – you may have limited time to find a quick solution like a bark collar i.e. this is the only choice as training classes might take too long.

It’s probably best practice not to leave your GSD alone with a bark collar on in case in case for whatever reason you have to manually step in.

Remember – you can use the collar on your dog for a short period of time until the barking stops, and either replace with their old collar, or a dummy anti bark collar.

It doesn’t have to be a permanent thing.

Always consult a qualified animal expert though for their advice on the matter.

 

Anti Bark Collar vs Shock Collar/E Collar – Differences and Similarities

Technically, there isn’t really a difference, but in reality there is.

A bark collar or anti bark collar is the name usually given to a self functioning collar that picks up either the sound of the bark and/or the vibration in the dog’s vocal cords when they bark.They do this with bark sensing technology.

It then delivers either a warning vibration or shock stimulation to the dog to alert them that barking is to be associated with an undesired stimulation (the electric pulse).

Shock collars, or, as they are called more frequently in modern times ‘e collars’, are used for more broad and general training and are controlled by a remote held by the owner.

E Collars also tend to have other warning options like vibrate and sound based warnings.

There are some anti bark collar’s like the ones from the Garmin brand for example that are compatible with Garmin e collar controllers, so they can do both.

There’s no reason you couldn’t use an e collar to manage and minimise your dog’s barking, as long as you are around to handle the controller. In fact, some owners prefer this.

 

Best Anti Bark Collar For German Shepherd: Resources

1. http://www.dogtra.com/

2. https://buy.garmin.com

3. http://www.sportdog.com/

 

“thedailyshep.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com”

“Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of Amazon.com Inc., or its affiliates”

 

Friendly Disclaimer 🙂 

TheDailyShep.com are not veterinarians, or animal professionals/experts. Information provided is for informational purposes only – it is not a substitute for professional or qualified advice.

The information is based on either our own thorough research, and/or own experiences, as a means of free speech.

By consuming this information, you accept that TheDailyShep.com do not have client or patient relationship with you, and TheDailyShep.com are not advising you to act on anything you read.

You should always consult your own veterinarian, animal expert, or health care professional and follow their advice before making decisions on all matters.

You can find our full set of disclaimers and T & C’s in the footer of this site.

Enjoy your reading, and thank you for being here 🙂 

Share.

About Author

Leave A Reply